Sure they can close the operculm and protect themselves but as soon as they start to crawl around again, the puffer will likely nip the foot and take pieces off. Use of this web site is subject to the terms and conditions described in the. I had almost no problems with her, although I did not tempt her much. A Valentini would probably do alright in the system you describe, but a totally safe alternative is the mimic filefish Paraluteres prionurus which mimics the Valentini puffer and looks almost identical and is total reef safe… Welcome to ReefCentral. There are no safe snails with a valentini. I had pretty much the same experience as others above - I wouldn't get another because of the clam and snail issues. Great fish with alot of personality. probably include a few brittle/serpent stars, might try a coral banded shrimp. Theyre pretty cool little species of puffers, if there some wat reef safe maybe ill take a chance? I have a pair in my full blown reef and they bother nothing. Shrimp, fish, cuttlefish, baby octopi, calamari, mussels on shell, spaced in tank for a some time - you will find more details by entering "puffer dentistry" in the search engine. I had a Valentini in my reef for several months and never really had any problems with him in regards to my SPS. He loved to just pop the bubbles on the bubble and nip on the hammer to the point that it brown jellied and died. I'm upgrading to MH's within the next week (yay!) Top Care Facts For The Valentini Puffer (Canthigaster valentini) Care Level: Easy Temperament: Peaceful Diet: Omnivore Origin: Indo Pacific Acclimation My other established zoas are not bothered. Not a huge problem, just meant that I couldn't buy any speck-sized frags. I can't feed him enough. Mine did at least. Even the Turbos and Astreas. He ignored softies and other fish, but he harassed plate corals and snails. He was gasping heavily, but his fins … from what I've heard the mimics are most likely to nip at SPS, and even though they may sample softies they usually learn quickly that they dont taste very good. I've never had a problem with them eating soft corals, and I don't have any stony, but mine was pretty tough on my hermits and snails. I feed mine with a grid feeding clip modified on a swingarm/piece of acrylic which allows me to remove the food after the puffer is full. Yeah I forgot to mention that part. He gets fed mysis and flakes daily. I also had a pencil urchin that went about its business (eating my corals) without ever being bothered. I've had my Valentini for about five months or so with mushrooms and zoo's and he's been a model fish. Overall though it's pretty doable. I too grew a very small valentini puffer to nearly-adult size in a reef tank. Please take a moment to acquaint yourself with our selling/trading rules to help make your stay a long and rewarding one. yea I had opened a thread like this last year and I end up buying one and returning him after he went after my ricordea. Because of the sheer size of our forum, we've been forced to limit selling and trading to members who've met a couple of criteria. I've caught him occasionally nipping at SPS growth tips as well, but not consistently, the corals have plenty of time to grow back before he realizes it didn't taste that great. Any fine chopped grocery seafood, frozen and thawed to kill the parasites, raw, without salt and preservatives. I finally setup a FOWLR tank and moved the Valentini to there. I'd really love one of these guys; from the fairly sizable amount of research I've done, it seems like these guys are feitsy, personable little fish who can sometimes turn on corals and will often eat snails and hermits. They are a fun little fish with lots of personality! Puffers and clams dont mix well, so be careful. I know that a Valentini Puffer is not reef safe, but I have done quite a bit of research and have found that many have had success with keeping it with corals and some inverts. I think you have better success with adding a more juvenile specimen. piscine tankmates would include my longnose hawk, yellowtail damsel, and YWG to be paired with a tiger pistol before the addition of the puffer. He would sometimes nip at the growth tips but never enough to really damage the coral, just slowed down the growth a little. It was never enough to cause the corals to die or rtn or anything, but enough that it slowed growth way down as he liked to eat the new growth tips. Anyone have any experience with them. It may not display this or other websites correctly. Never bothered any of the Shrimp or Crabs though. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. And now I have a couple new small sps and it's been nipping at them...mostly the Birds of Paradise. Kenya tree, white lemnalia, GSP, BrownSP, yellow polyps, anthelia, white xenia, red mushrooms, green hairy mushrooms, candycane, hammers, frogspawns, blastomussa merletti, scolymia, lobophyllia, acan echino, chili and sun coral (these two require personal care, but they live well in tank with valentini puffer). He's eaten a couple hermits and a couple turbos. I'd like to have my rather large (2"+) electric blue hermit in here as well. Mine sampled too: frogpawn and sun coral, the first didn't slower growth or inflation (was bitten a couple of times only), the sun coral looks like being very disgusting at his taste - tried once, spit without resampling spitted, and never tried again. I'd love to include one in the dedicated soft coral dominated tank Im planning to setup, mostly softies and mushrooms, nothing especially tasty. This species is the most docile of the puffers. Valentini Puffer for sale 4Less! I've lost a few zoa frags to it. Because of the sheer size of our forum, we've been forced to limit selling and trading to members who've met a couple of criteria. Use of this web site is subject to the terms and conditions described in the. He never seemed to bother a single coral that was in the tank when he was first introduced, but just about every coral I added after him was sampled at least once and some even more. He is really fond of zoos, but hasnt touched any of my softies, or the galaxea, frogspawn, hammer, and gorgonia. She occassionally picked at a snail or two, but most learned to press up against whatever they were grazing on as she swam by (and I never saw her actually get a snail off a rock -- but she would nip at them if they were exposed.) I just put a fiji puffer in my small reef tank the other day. Or something inbetween, adding the puffer to a tank with a few hardy, quick growers like Xenia and Birdsnet for SPS, tell he learns there's better food? It may have nipped at soft corals, but I had enough it wasn't noticeable. Not sure there is anything I can do, but I figured I should try. I'm thinking I will do the mimic filefish after all, apparently the puffers often nip at perching fish like hawks, so they're out. A Valentini would probably do alright in the system you describe, but a totally safe alternative is the mimic filefish Paraluteres prionurus which mimics the Valentini puffer and looks almost identical and is total reef safe. he hasnt caused to much havok, mostly just sampling, like someone else said. Please take a moment to acquaint yourself with our selling/trading rules to help make your stay a long and rewarding one. You are using an out of date browser. This species is … JavaScript is disabled. Of feeding toby or sharpnose puffers. Welcome to ReefCentral. That being said, the gorgonia would be a great choice for you, its non-photosynthetic and won't require any lighting upgrades, just the occasional feeding. I really loved that little toby -- she was a very interesting fish and I wouldn't hesitate to get another one. I looked into diamonds of the reef, but cant find anything on how one actually gets the livestock- are they shipped out? They're certainly not going to be as coral-safe as a fairy wrasse - mine nipped at any "new and interesting" sps I added to the tank until they weren't "new" anymore - about a week. (If you're seeing this message, you haven't met them yet.) Great fish. They're certainly not going to be as coral-safe as a fairy wrasse - mine nipped at any "new and interesting" sps I added … I had a female for a few years, during which time she grew from very very small to close to her adult size. I know that a Valentini Puffer is not reef safe, but I have done quite a bit of research and have found that many have had success with keeping it with corals and some inverts. If it's one of your favorite fish and you're willing to keep a somewhat limited range of LPS, go for it. For example, mine will eat shrimp and snails but will not touch crabs. or you pick them up? (If you're seeing this message, you haven't met them yet.) I had a mature cleaner shrimp, a serpent star and a brittle star (both of whom had cover under rocks), and some gorgonians and soft corals that the toby never bothered. Upon being put into the tank she pretty much desimated the hitchhiker feather dusters that were on my live rock (but I think she was just hungry, because later she showed no interest in the few that lived.) You must log in or register to reply here. and will finally be adding some harder corals, and I hope he continues to do great. Woke up this morning and my Valentini Puffer was lying on his side on the bottom of my tank. Similarly, she seemed to enjoy going after hermit crabs, but I don't believe she ever ate one. I learned to be very careful and had no problems after that. I too grew a very small valentini puffer to nearly-adult size in a reef tank. He did however seem to like killing my Hammers and my Bubble coral. I noticed the biggest problem with mine, was when I added new corals to the tank after him. Do you guys think more success would come from adding one to an established with tons of corals already, or adding the fish first and building the corals up? Mine jumped twice when it was in my 55g - in both cases, it was spooked by "the hand". I will say the zoa frags were new, and under some stress from acclimating...but they never had a chance to recover. Filefish recenly tried sun babies - they closed for a while, but restored. I have one now, and thinking of trading it in for another. some sites saying there some wat reef safe, some say no. I've got a Fiji blue-spotted puffer, which I believe is similar to the Valentini.

China Lake Flex Friday Calendar 2020, I Love You Forever In Roman Numerals, 11 American Nations Quiz, Letters Of Administration Texas, Do Brainy And Nia Get Back Together In Season 5, Pictures Of Kitchens With Bisque Appliances, Goat Bloat Dr Pepper, El Catrin Meaning, Caroline Lyrics Colter Wall,